Tips for Buying a Beginner Road Bike

As I mentioned in my Giant Cypress Review, after not riding a bike for 20 years a hybrid bike was a good start back — however after a couple of months I realized that I really wanted a road bike.  While I liked those quiet rides alone in the country, there was a local bike club with some really neat longer rides where I could both get great exercise and socialize a bit with others who enjoyed bicycling.  Most towns have similar clubs — but, to keep up with the pace on those group rides I needed a more “serious” bike.

Remember, I am a cheapskate who started out looking for a bike under $200 to ride around with the kids and maybe do some exercise.  Now, I was looking at more serious riding and more serious cash.  Having now gone through the process, here are my Tips for Buying a Beginner Road Bike:

  • Get Ready to Spend Some Money.  As I said, I’m pretty cheap.  That said, remember this is not just some bike that you are going to ride around the block with the kids — this is a bike that you’ll be (a) exercising strenuously on; (b) spending a decent bit of time on; (c) be riding miles away from home on; and (d) approaching speeds of 50 miles per hour going down some hills (remember your bike helmet!).  Given all of that, it really is worth it to spend more.  Yes, you can get a cheap bike from a big-box-retailer, but if you do the research (and I have) on those, you’ll see that most of the reviews of those have tons of complaints — and also, those cheap bikes are usually a lot heavier also (which matters up hills).  After trying to be cheaper, but doing my homework, I finally realized I would be much better off with a more expensive bike from a bike shop.  And now, in retrospect, if I had it to do over again I might actually spend more than I did.  I’ve spent hours on my bike, and when you think about it, for that amount of time cycling is actually a less expensive hobby than golf or most other hobbies.  So, how much is the minimum?  I’d say that for a new road bike, you’ll probably have to spend around $700 to get a new, decent quality beginner road bike.
  • Flat Bar or Bent? In recent years road bikes with flat bars have become popular as “fitness bikes”, because they allow a more upright riding position and can be more comfortable on your hands.  Actually, for those who haven’t ridden a road bike recently, you should know that most road bike riders with conventional bent handlebars these days spend most of their time on the “tops” and “hoods” (top of the brake/shifter), and not a lot on the “drops” (lower portion).   Also, to save weight most bikes with bent bars combine the brake and the shifter levers (you squeeze it to brake, move it sideways to shift), so most people riding with bent bars also need biking gloves, because if you ride very far with your grip around the brakes/shifters, it is not that comfortable bare-handed.   That said, I would probably recommend bent handlebars unless you have a bad back and need to ride more upright.  In any event, you may want to test drive both kinds to see what you like.
  • Brand/Components. As I mentioned before, you should probably buy a “bike store brand” of bike, rather than one at your local big-box-retailer.  That will usually get you into good bikes like Trek, Giant, Cannondale, Specialized, Fuji, Scott, and the better Schwinns (much different from the Schwinns sold at big-box stores).  This will usually get you a bike with a good frame and decent quality components.  Most likely your crank/cassette/shifters will be some version of Shimano — the more you pay, the better version you get (Shimano 105 is generally better than Shimano Tiagra, which is generally better than Shimano Sora/Shimano 2300).  If I had it to do over again, I probably would go with at least Tiagra, rather than Sora that my bike has.  Oh, and make sure you are happy with the brakes too!
  • Double or Triple Crank? One component in particular is the crank (where the pedal arms go into, that turns the chain).  Most beginner road bikes have a “triple crank”, meaning their are 3 rings of gears on the crank, while a lot of more expensive bikes have a double or compact crank, with only 2 rings of gears.  I think most beginners can benefit from having a triple crank (making hills a little easier), and many experienced riders still use triple cranks in hilly areas.
  • Frame. Road bike frames can vary a good bit — some with slanted top tubes that allow a shorter reach and require a less-bent-over riding position, some with long top tubes that require a lot of bending over, etc.  Frames also come in different sizes that are not consistent among different manufacturers.  This is where a good bike shop comes in handy, so you can sit on different types and get fitted by a professional.
  • Fit. There are lots of places for adjustment on a road bike, and since you’ll be spending a good bit of time and exercising vigorously on it, you should be sure to get a good fit.  From deciding between Medium and Medium/Large to adjusting seat height, seat position, handlbar height, handlebar position, etc., having a pro at your local bike shop help you really can be worth the money to help you avoid strain/pain that a bad fit could lead to.
  • Where to Buy. As you may be able to tell, if you are a beginner cyclist I would seriously recommend that you buy a road bike from your local bike shop instead of a big-box-retail store or online merchants.  I love saving money as much as anyone, and do a lot of my shopping online, but for a starter road bike you really need to go in and try out different bikes, take one around the block (most bike shops allow this), and get a good fitting (most shops will help some, though some charge $$ for a really detailed fitting).  Also, every road bike will need adjusting after about a month or so of riding (during this time brake lines and shifter lines stretch a little, and other things shift a bit) and every good bike shop includes this in the price — while most big-box retailers either can’t do it or charge extra for it.
  • Buy New or Used? With eBay and Craigslist and other online marketplaces, there are some good deals around if you know exactly what you want and either trust the seller or can inspect it before you buy it.  Like cars, with used bikes you could be buying someone else’s problems — and end up with a lot of repair bills.  For this reason, and the reasons above, I think beginner road bike buyers should probably stick to a new bike from a local shop.  However, there are some good deals on used bikes also — so if you decide to buy used, I would definitely budget to have a shop inspect it (if possible) and give it a tune-up (definitely) before you ride miles from home on it.
  • Extras. Don’t forget to budget a little extra for the inevitable extras.  You will have to have a water bottle cage (holder) and big water bottle on your bike for sure.  Also, some road bikes don’t come with pedals (since some riders like to choose their own).  Many beginner road bikes come with cheap seats that you’ll want to replace quickly.  Road bike tires are high-pressure and need to be pumped before each ride — and they usually have a smaller valve (a Presta valve) than other bike and car tires, so you need a pump or adapter that work with those valves.  And, don’t forget a bicycle helmet — I never wore one when I was growing up, but remember you might even get up around 50 M.P.H. going downhill on a road bike, so better safe than sorry.

In my next post I’ll let you know what I chose for my beginner road bicycle and give a detailed review of my bike.  Until then, please be sure to use the comments form below for comments and questions.

Giant Beginner Triathlon Road Bike Complete Set Up
End Date: Thursday Dec-14-2017 18:33:23 PST
Buy It Now for only: $750.00
Buy It Now | Add to watch list

Cycling Plus Road Test Grand Jury Bike Of Year Beginner May 2015 FREE SHIPPING!
End Date: Monday Dec-18-2017 11:43:48 PST
Buy It Now for only: $17.97
Buy It Now | Add to watch list

Men's Health September 1996. Beginners Guide To Road Biking! (gay interest)
End Date: Sunday Dec-10-2017 14:42:51 PST
Buy It Now for only: $9.99
Buy It Now | Add to watch list

11 comments to Tips for Buying a Beginner Road Bike

  • What’s the best way to make someone feel loved?…

    Adventures in Living a Healthy, Juicy Life by Cheryl Ragsdale Welcome to the February 14, 2010 edition of staying young – from the inside out.  This week we are pleased to present Annabel Candy (great name for Valentine’s day) with her thou…

  • Total Mind and Body Fitness Blog Carnival 141…

    Monday is Blog Carnivals Day. A Blog Carnival is basically a collection of articles or blog posts, all relating to a similar subject, that are gathered together for your viewing pleasure. You can quickly and conveniently see a list of Article Titles an…

  • […] Cycling presents Tips for Buying a Beginner Road Bike posted at Beginner Cycling, saying, "Road bikes are a great way to exercise — here's […]

  • With Spring on the way and more people getting out, biking is a great way to stay fit, have good quality family time and maybe even lose weight. The tips you have put out here are great and I am including this article in the healthy blog carnival coming out on my site tomorrow. Thanks for a great article.

  • admin

    Thanks for the kind words, and thanks for including me in the carnival!

  • […] Hiking 101 posted at – Local Writing from the Heartland   Beginner Cycling presents Tips for Buying a Beginner Road Bike posted at Beginner Cycling, saying, “Road bicycles are a great way to exercise — […]

  • […] healthy lifestyle. With Spring coming it is important to get outside. Beginner Cycling presents Tips for Buying a Beginner Road Bike posted at Beginner Cycling, saying, “Road bikes are a great way to stay fit — […]

  • Sexy Organic Blog Carnival 1…

    Welcome to my very first Blog Carnival. If you’re not sure exactly what that is its just a bunch of posts from different bloggers put together on similar topics. I’ll get more of a hang of it as time goes on so enjoy and keep those submissi…

  • I agree with Deb!! I really liked this article. I don’t think I’ve seen a cycling article so complete. I will definitely use it for me and recommend it to my friends. Thanks a lot!!

  • Victor


    About 3 months ago I bought a Scott Sportster P6 hybrid weighs a little over
    27 lbs. This was for a charity ride, my mountain bike was over 20 years old and I didn’t know if it could make the 35 miles without falling apart + the area where I live is not road bike friendly. I’m 4 months later my dad says we are moving closer to my brother and there they have group rides, clubs etc. I plan on joining them on their rides but I don’t think I will be able to reach 20+ mph on my bike. I’ve been thinking if I should trade in my bike for a road bike? what would you do in this situation?

  • admin

    Hi Victor,

    I’d be inclined to wait until you move to see what kind of riding you’ll actually be doing. The Scott Sportster P6 seems like a pretty good bike, though I’ve seen some mention that the gearing is not optimal for speed. See what kind of club rides, etc. that you will be doing. In clubs that grade rides by difficulty/miles, it’s not unusual to see folks on D and C level rides on hybrids — so you could definitely ride your Sportster on a couple of those without having to change bikes (though most people will probably be on road bikes). You’ll probably eventually want to get a road bike if you keep doing road rides — hybrids are versatile, but they are “jacks of all trades, masters of none”.

    Happy Riding!

Leave a Reply




You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>